| To
Pick the Best Hospital Use Your Right to Know
There's
often no time to research the hospital before you need it.
But for everything from a scheduled surgical procedure to
childbirth, you may have some breathing room, and it's worth
investing a little time in research. Hospitals are not all
the same, and some may be able to provide better care for
your specific needs than others. Because some specialists
only have privileges at selected hospitals, your choice of
doctor and hospital may go together.
According
to a recently released survey of 21,000 consumers by Consumer
Reports magazine, the most important factors for good quality
care include sufficient staff (especially registered nurses),
good systems in place for organizing the care, and experience
with your particular medical condition.
The
Good Life compiled the following helpful tips based on
things we learned researching this story and published advice
from a number of different consumer and healthcare groups.
If
you have insurance, does your health plan or employer provide
a tool to compare the hospitals in your network with one another?
Like
Aetna, a number of large national insurers now provide on-line
tools for enrollees trying to select a hospital. The Texas
Business Group on Health (TBGH) provides such a tool for the
employees of its members. Dell Inc. and HEB are members, as
well as a number of other area businesses. Ask if your employer
is a member, or check for yourself at www.tbgh.org/members.htm.
You can use these tools, or others listed below, to answer
some of the following questions.
Does
the hospital regularly treat your condition?
High-volume
hospitals tend to have better outcomes, according to most
research. You can ask the hospital how many procedures like
yours they do every year, and compare that to other local
hospitals. For many procedures, especially those that relate
to heart care or childbirth, you can look up the procedure
volume on-line, along with selected mortality rates. For the
most recent available Texas state data, go directly to the
hospital-by-hospital comparison tables for your procedure
at www.thcic.state.tx.us/IQIReport2001/IQIReport2001.htm.
For
an easier to use set of comparisons, there are some on-line
"hospital report cards" that will provide a wide
range of information. For free information about Austin area
hospitals, try www.healthgrades.com.
Other
free on-line report cards tested by The Good Life did
not yet include Texas hospital data, which only became available
last year.
How
many patients are there for each registered nurse (RN) in
the unit that you will need?
Recent
studies indicate that each additional patient more than four
in a nurse's workload increases the risk that patients will
die (see main article, "How Safe is Your Hospital?").
The National Nurses Alliance says there should be no more
than four patients for every RN on general medical-surgical
units. Proposed mandatory staffing laws in Congress and in
several states provide guidelines for staff ratios advocated
by nurses. Ask how the hospital's staffing compares to these
guidelines. Texas hospitals are not accustomed to giving out
this information, so you may have to insist!
Are
there doctors available in all the specialties you will need?
Ask
your primary doctor what specialty doctors you are likely
to require for your treatment, and what kind of specialists
would you likely need if something goes wrong. Check to see
if the hospital has a full range of these specialists available.
Will
your care be coordinated by a single physician?
Depending
on the complexity of your treatment, you may be visited by
a number of different doctors, nurses and specialists. To
reduce the chance of overlapping or conflicting orders, ask
if your care can be coordinated by a single physician that
you will see each day.
Is
the hospital fully accredited?
All
the hospitals in Austin covered in this report have received
full accreditation by the Joint Commission on Accreditation
of Healthcare Organizations (JCAHO) and are in good standing.
As you narrow down your choice of hospitals, check the accreditation
status at www.jcaho.org/qualitycheck/directry/directry.asp.
Ask the hospital about any outstanding issues for improvement.
How
do infection and error rates compare with national benchmarks?
Most
hospitals will not tell you the infection rates or error rates
associated with your procedure, although most track some or
all of this information. But hospitals should be able to tell
you how their infection rates compare with averages published
by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). If
you are scheduling a surgery, ask whether the hospital's post-surgical
infection rates are better, worse, or comparable to CDC benchmarks.
You can also ask if the hospital has had to report any "sentinel
events" to an accreditation body related to the treatment
you need. A "sentinel event" is a complication that
results in death or serious injury to a patient.
What
programs does the hospital have in place to reduce errors
and improve patient safety?
The
Leapfrog Group, a coalition of more than 140 public and private
organizations that provide healthcare benefits, recommends
that hospitals computerize physician orders to reduce medication
errors. Other recommendations include incorporating a pharmacist
into daily rounds. Adequate infection control staff is also
important. Ask whether the hospital has one or more full-time
infection control specialists coordinating infection-reduction
programs, and ask about the hospital's initiatives to reduce
medical errors.
Is
there a patient representative or ombudsman on staff?
If
so, ask what services this person can provide during your
hospital stay. If not, ask how complaints are handled.
What
do other patients have to say about their treatment at the
hospital?
Ask
around. You may be surprised how many people you know who
have recently visited a local hospital and have something
to say about the experience. Ask them what they liked, and
what they noticed about their hospital care. The federal Agency
for Healthcare Research and Quality suggests you ask the hospital
for a copy of its most recent patient satisfaction survey.
Hospitals are not required to release patient satisfaction
surveys, but it doesn't hurt to ask.
Special
questions parents should ask about their birthing hospital
New
parents should ask the same questions about staffing, medical
errors, infection and coordination of care that other patients
ask, but there are a number of special questions you can ask
to identify the best hospital to have your baby, as follows;
(1)
Are nurses trained in neonatal resuscitation available at
all times, and does the hospital have its own neonatal intensive
care unit?
Hopefully
very few parents will experience the tragedy that drove the
Ogle family into court over the birth of their daughter (see
main article, "How Safe is Your Hospital?"). Ask
the hospital to specifically describe how they would handle
a sudden emergency requiring skilled resuscitation of your
newborn child.
(2)
How does the hospital's Caesarian-section rate compare to
the state average?
This
information is available at www.thcic.state.tx.us. You can
also ask the hospital. A lower C-section rate may indicate
better care.
(3)
Will a nurse or midwife be available throughout labor at your
request?
Adequate
nursing attention during the whole course of labor reduces
C-section rates and increases family satisfaction, according
to Lourdes Hospital in New York.
(4)
Does the hospital have an anesthesiologist on staff at all
times?
Peg
Moline, editor of Fit Pregnancy magazine, recommends that
even if you don't intend to use drugs during labor that you
should ensure there is flexibility to change your mind.
(5)
Does the hospital provide a place for the father to sleep,
and how does it handle visitors?
Your
comfort, and your ability to be together as a new family,
is important too.
-Kathy
Mitchell
|